Friday, January 14, 2011

Review: The Hunger Games Trilogy by Suzanne Collins



Reviewed by Connie

First of all -- happy birthday to the wonderful, amazing, intelligent, dedicated, one and only Ingrid! My successor who is doing a marvelous job running The Blue Bookcase!

Published: 2008, 2009, and 2010

It's about: I don't want to give too much away, as most of the enjoyment of these books comes from the suspense of not knowing what's going to happen. So, the scene: North America in the future, which has become one political entity called Panem, whose 12 districts are ruled by an Orwellian Capitol. To remind the districts of the Capitol's omnipotence, every year the Capitol hosts an event called the Hunger Games, in which one boy and one girl from each district are ushered into a deathly arena, where they must kill each other, Gladiator style, on live television, until only one "victor" remains.

Enter, Katniss Everdeen -- not your typical 15-year-old girl -- driven by the survival instinct,she does anything necessary (including hunting illegally with her deadly bow and arrow) to keep her mother and sister alive.

A dystopian young adult series, this trilogy is a story of survival, of revolution, of government, of love, and of whether humans are ever capable of building a better future.

I thought: I read these books pretty quickly, about one a day over my Christmas break, partly because so many people had been pushing me to read them, and partly because I was really excited to use my fabulous Christmas present -- my Kindle!

For the most part, I didn't want to put the (e)books down -- the storyline is engaging, exciting, and oftentimes dangerous, and the characters have just the right amount of unpredictability. This is the kind of trilogy I stay up a little too late at night reading, because I really want to find out what happens (with the exception of the first half of Mockingjay, which I had a hard time getting into).

One of the best aspects of these books is the strong, non-stereotypical female protagonist, Katniss. Especially with other YA books floating around there with such horribly needy, overly emotional, self-destructive female characters whose entire happiness centers around a boy or two (*cough* TWILIGHT *cough*), it is refreshing to find a leading lady in a YA series who is strong-willed, logical, and independent, who, though certainly not devoid of love, does not center all of her thoughts and actions around it.

All of this being said, I will not say this is a masterpiece of work. Enjoyable? Yes. Difficult to put down? Yes. Great characters? Yes. But is this rife with literary merit? I may make some people angry with this, but I'd say no. It has its moments, but it is certainly too flawed to be at the level of The Book Thief (read my review here) or even the Harry Potter series in terms of its universality, writing quality, and ability to tie its themes and emotionally frayed edges together into a neat work of wonderfulness.

I realize that I'm being a bit vague, but in a nutshell, I enjoyed the series, I look forward to seeing the movie adaptations, and though it did not offend my literary senses, it did not excite them either.

Verdict: I'd say borrow this series from someone else's shelf when you want a fun read that's sheer entertainment

Reading Recommendations: These books are best read in as few sittings as possible, as they are action-packed and exciting

Warnings: A few pretty mildly graphic deaths but nothing to lose sleep over

This is really random, but as everyone puts in their votes for which actors should play the main characters in the upcoming movie adaptation of these novels, the only actor I can think of for any part is Simon Baker to play Finnick:





Favorite excerpts: "A mockingjay is a creature the Capitol never intended to exist. They hadn't counted on the highly controlled jabberjay having the brains to adapt to the wild, to pass on its genetic code, to thrive in a new form. They hadn't anticipated its will to live." Catching Fire


What I'm reading next: Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen

Comments (44)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I would disagree with you on the literary merit, except perhaps in Catching Fire, which was the least literary of the bunch (and my least favorite). I've spent multiple book groups reaching into the depths and themes particularly of the first book, and wrote up a whole literary analysis review on Mockingjay back when it came out. I think perhaps the difference is that you read all of them quickly, rather than savouring the non-plot elements that are definitely in there. The first time I read them, that's what I did too, but I've read The Hunger Games 4 more times and the others more than once too, and I read them slowly, taking my time to really look around in it. I would say there is probably more literary elements to this series than Harry Potter, even though I really do love HP.
1 reply · active 741 weeks ago
Couldn't agree more with your evaluation--engaging story with a fast pace that, in the last book at least, asks uncomfortable political questions. But not literature, no. They're a little too ephemeral.
1 reply · active 741 weeks ago
Thanks for the review. I thought I was the only one on the planet who didn't think these were the greatest books ever written. Enjoyable, yes - haven't read Mockingjay yet, but I intend to - but very flawed. I hated the present tense. The only time it came close to working was the immediacy of the arena, otherwise the book would have been better served in the past tense, maybe even 3rd person.
1 reply · active 741 weeks ago
I haven't read these and so I obviously don't know anything about Finnick, but I appreciate you including a photo of handsome Simon Baker. :)
I'm curious to hear what you think about Water for Elephants. Hope you'll have time to review it!
I think we have pretty much the same view on these. I ate up the first two and waited impatiently for a year for the third, but ended up having to re-read the second in order to remember what was happening at the start of the third, so reading them all close together is a good idea.

I LOVED the first two books, and the third had its moments, but I was disappointed by the third overall, and would go so far as to say the ending kind of ruined the series for me.

It was a great escapist read though. And I recommend it highly. (Especially so I can discuss the ending!)
3 replies · active 688 weeks ago
I thought they were great, more because she wasn't afraid to really put the characters in life threatening danger. I'm not sure I'd read them again, but they had such vivid imagery despite the imaginary dystopian world, I'd love to see them translated to film.
I don't usually read YA, but I really want to read this trilogy. It sounds like the perfect read for evenings after stressful days at work, when I just want to escape.
1 reply · active 741 weeks ago
I mean to read these books when I get the time (sigh.) I read her previous series with my son- The Underland Chronicles- which was targeted to middle grade and doesn't get much buzz. It was quite good, although somewhat disturbing in its themes for a middle grade book because of the violence and the overall depressing view of human nature. As far as literary merit-- I enjoyed it as much as my son and it gave us both something deeper to think about. For a MG adventure book, I'm pretty pleased with that.
1 reply · active 741 weeks ago
I was less enthusiastic about this series than most. I enjoyed it quite a bit but wasn't floored by it.
i am addicted to the hunger games! <3 i stayed up all night to read it a second time lol i dunno it is just that good. i am so excited to see the movie when it comes out!! http://on.fb.me/gXrImz
1 reply · active 741 weeks ago
Thanks for the review. These seem worth checking out, especially for the strong female character. This may get me in trouble, but good to hear someone else who was a little put off by the wimpiness of Bella in the Twilight books.
1 reply · active 741 weeks ago
Definitely a series I truly enjoyed, although Mockingjay left me a little empty. The Hunger Games was excellent, though, and a quick read as well. I'd say it certainly reinforced for me that I really do like a post-apocalyptic/dystopian setting for some of the books I read.
1 reply · active 739 weeks ago
I agree with the comments on how Hunger Games was the best of the three. The book was recommended to me by many people, and when I finally sat down to read it, I was captivated by the first few chapters and finished it in a day. I then read Catching Fire in 2 days, and it took me 4 days to read Mockingjay, but it was really because I wanted to know the end, and not because I truly enjoyed reading through the novel. That being said, I believe that Suzanne is a good author, but her style of writing simply does not compare to that of J.K. Rowling's. You always know a series is good when every single book is more or less just as good and entertaining as the other, as is the Harry Potter series.
I agree with you that the characters are unpredictable. I especially like how Katniss is totally independant and relies on herself to survive. It is true that the first half of Mockingjay was a bit slow, but I think that the last half makes up for it. I really enjoyed reading this series and I also can't wait for the movie.
I agree with you that the characters are unpredictable. I especially like how Katniss is totally independant and relies on herself to survive. It is true that the first half of Mockingjay was a bit slow, but I think that the last half makes up for it. I really enjoyed reading this series and I also can't wait for the movie.
i've heard good things about these books and I'd love to read this series, but i don't own any of them ):
I really enjoyed this book mainly because of Katniss and the strong writing(: Katniss was very strong and appealing as a female character, which is always great to see in books haha.
I have wanted to try this series as I have heard this series is really good.
Clarissa Pereira's avatar

Clarissa Pereira · 718 weeks ago

I've heard this series is good. I haven't been able to find a copy in my country though.
Good review. I haven't read the series yet but have heard it's good, and am so glad that the main character isn't some twilight-esque wimp.
I can't wait for these books to me made into movies!
SarahSparrow's avatar

SarahSparrow · 718 weeks ago

I keep hearing about these books and I'm really interested in reading them. I work at my local public library and I've seen The Hunger Games stay on the shelf for, literally, a couple hours at best. I have yet to see a bad review of them.
Kah_Cherub's avatar

Kah_Cherub · 718 weeks ago

This sounds pretty good! I know how you feel about your new Kindle. *-* LOL I'll have to read those before the movie comes out! :)

Post a new comment

Comments by