Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Top Ten Tuesday: Mean Girls Meagan Wants To Punch In The Face


So this week's Top Ten Tuesday topic from The Broke and the Bookish = Best. Topic. Ever. I (Meagan) get to list the Top Ten Mean Girls I've come across in my reading and that I'd just love to punch in the face. Sweet!

Let me explain: I'm coming off a brutal two straight weeks on the road for work and have been averaging about 5 hours of sleep a night. What I'd really like is to be put a medically induced coma until I recover, but a good second-best option for relieving stress is griping about people I seriously dislike. And if these people are fictional, so much the better--then there's no need for guilt (:

You may recognize a few characters on this list from one of my previous posts but I'll try and come up with some new characters I love to hate.

1. Hattie - Okay, I'm going to go on a tangent right at the get-go and rant a little bit about the movie version of Ella Enchanted. I LOVED the book and was excited to see it translated to film. But when I went to see the film I was SO angry. I doubt a single person on that project actually read the book. If I had the money a remake of this movie would be high on the list of projects I'd tackle. ANYWAY, in Ella Enchanted the novel, Hattie is the oldest, ugliest, and evilest of Ella's two step sisters and her cruelty literally makes my skin crawl. If I could I'd punch her face AND steal her wig. 
2. Darcy Rhone - Something Borrowed was Emily Giffin's first and, in my opinion, best book and is also about to make its debut as a film. In the novel, Darcy is a perfect example of that privileged girl we love to hate. She's the lethal combination of a girl who thinks she's all that and actually does have it all. But she doesn't stop there, she has to have everyone else's all as well. Her selfishness and shallowness are impressive and I'd like nothing better than to knock her down a few pegs.
3. Sarah Reed - Is anyone else seeing a pattern here? Maybe books with truly awful characters are just as much of a draw as intriguing protagonists. Jane Eyre also made another appearance on the big screen with Sally Hawkins making a surprising appearance as this most awful of aunts. I still can't get over the fact that she called Jane to her deathbed just to make sure Jane realized just how much she was hated. What a piece of work!
4. Elizabeth Gilbert - Okay, so Elizabeth  represents more of a type that bothers me than how I feel about her character specifically. But whiny women who don't really have anything to whine about drive me crazy. Oh, I'm so rich I can afford to give up all my belongings and live abroad for years my life is so hard.  Oh, I'm so gorgeous than men everywhere fall at my feet but nobody can give me what I need. Oh, I'm all about asserting my independence but I'm not complete unless I have a man. Whine. Whine Whine. I may punch her, but only after duct-taping her obnoxious mouth shut (:
5. Scarlett O'Hara - I know, I know. She's an iconic character and everybody loves her. Everybody except me. I didn't like Scarlett from the beginning, but she became irredeemably unlikable when she stole her sister's beau, married him, and then wasn't even sorry when he was killed. I know many (if not most) of you disagree with me on this, but frankly, my dears.... (:
6. Ruth - I know I talk about Never Let Me Go but this is another list where it fits perfectly. Ruth's selfish actions in knowingly keeping Tommy and Kathy apart just so she wouldn't be alone are awful in themselves, but when you add that tragic circumstances of their doomed love and lives their separation seems almost too much to bear. None of the characters deserve their endings, but Ruth more than the others deserves some sort of punishment for her selfishness.
7. Hilly Holbrook - Hilly is a masterful representation of everything that was truly wrong with the South in the '60s. Brutal forces like the KKK were (and unfortunately still are) truly awful institutions but I believe a deeper insidiousness came from the attitudes of the women. Because it was from these women that children learned to judge and hate. Hilly is a small-minded, manipulative bigot who is dangerous because she is socially revered. I literally clapped my hands when I discovered the comeuppance she was handed for her unforgivable attitude.
8. Bella Swan - Sorry, but can't have a hater list without mentioning our favorite obnoxious, shallow, irrelevant heroine. 
9. Rebeckah Emerson - Familial betrayal is awful, but most especially in wartime. You may have your differences, but if your actions willfully cause harm to your family, then I have no sympathy at all for your welfare. During the Revolutionary War, Tory Rebeckah goes beyond believing she is right to personally attacking her sister Jemima, and deliberately tries to shame and guilt her. What a gem, right? Some Tories had viable reasons for their support of the British Crown, but she sure doesn't do anything for their image.
10. Dolores Umbridge - It seems like no list is complete without a reference to Harry Potter, and I think she represents the worst of the worst. Never mind you know who's desire to kill Harry, Dolores just wanted to hurt him. And she did it in the most sadistic way possible. Carving his skin with a pen? Really? Somehow I don't think a punch to the face would quite be enough...

Comments (23)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Dani@BornExpat's avatar

Dani@BornExpat · 726 weeks ago

Scarlett and Umbridge made my list as well, though I do like Scarlett despite her selfish, man-stealing ways. I feel conflicted about Ruth. It was a terrible thing that she did, keeping Tommy and Kathy apart, but I think she truly regretted doing it and paid for it in the end. Guh, I love that book so much but it's so heartbreaking.
Is your Elizabeth Gilbert the author of Eat, Pray, Love? Ha-ha, I felt the same way about her. If not, sorry didn't mean to offend. :) We had several similar mean gals on our lists.
We have a few of the same choices. I love your inclusion of Bella, girl does need a good slapping.

Rachel-Endless Reading
This is my favorite post on the Blue Bookcase, and I agree with all the ones that I recognized. I don't think I have ever hated a character more than I hated Dolores Umbridge. She was pure evil.

But I also loved that Hattie made the list.

And I have always hated Scarlett. So I'm glad to see her on the list as well.
I definitely agree with scarlet o hara! Biggest bitch ever! I saw someone had Melanie on their list though, and I was like 'oh no you didn't!'
I had Scarlett too....but oh dear, how did I forget Bella Swan?! I can't believe I left her out lol.
I almost put Ruth on my list too but because I also felt sorry for her I decided to leave her off. You are right though she did deserve something for keeping Kathy and Tommy apart for her own selfish reasons. I LOVE Scarlett O'Hara but agree with everything you said about her. She is a character I love to hate. Also hated Dolored Umbridge.
I can't stand Ella Enchanted (the movie). It makes my skin crawl.

Women I'd like to smack with a Mallet
I completely agree about Scarlett, and I put her on my list too (we also have Hilly in common). I love your blog - I'm following :-)
I don't like Scarlett. I thought she was so selfish and mean. I don't know what's so great about her at all...or Rhett Butler. I mean, pushing a pregnant woman down the stairs. I fail to see the romance.

Bella Swan, well, I don't hate her, but she's just pining over a creepy vamp guy. Ugh.

Dolores, what's to like about her? She's wretched.
Your description of Elizabeth Gilbert had me laughing out loud! I read Eat Pray Love years ago and loved it, but the more time went by the more it bugged me for all the reasons you state - so true.

Good list too! I have Mrs Reed but totally forgot about Scarlett - she's perfectly bitchy.
Great list. Seems people are hating on the same characters.

Scarlett is a great choice! It's rare where the annoying girl is the heroine or anti-hero in this case.
Dolores made my list too. I agree that Scarlett is mean and contriving but she does hold a place in my heart.
I put Darcy on my list too. I hated her in the first book, and I totally didn't buy her reformation in the second....she doesn't deserve John Krasinski! ;)
I totally agree with your inclusion of Hilly. What an awful human being. Hated her!

As for Ruth in Never Let Me Go, I don’t know. For some reason throughout the whole book I always just felt sorry for her. She was obviously so angry at the entire situation I couldn’t feel any hatred towards her, no matter how selfish she was being.
I got a few common with you. Check those out
http://readbookswritepoetry.blogspot.com/2011/04/...
Hilly Holbrook was the first one who came to my mind when I saw this topic.
Ruth was the first name that came into my head when I saw the list for this week.
Don't apologize! Scarlett, Bella, and the Gilbert girl are on MOST people's villainess list! Although I must admit, Gone With the Wind is still one of my favorite books. Despite hating Scarlett, I still manage to care what happens to her. But not the other two...
Hattie was the first one on my list too! Ugh her character just made me so mad. And I considered putting Umbridge on the list, if it had been longer I'm sure she would have made it on.
Hilly was on my list - soooo evil. I also agree with your comments about Elizabeth Gilbert.

Reading Lark's Top 10
Bella Swan for sure. Another favorite i love to hate is Delores Umbridge.. i mean really, if there is any woman i want to set on fire, she'd be it.
Wow, I didn't realize there were so many Scarlet haters out there! :) I guess she's my favorite female fiction character because she goes through so much loss, so many hard things and she emerges strong and resourceful and hopeful through it all. There aren't many bold, powerful, strong women in fiction and so she represents the best, I think. Which is exactly why I can't stand Bella, Nothing admirable about her at all.

Post a new comment

Comments by