Thursday, September 15, 2011

Review: The Bean Trees by Barbara Kingsolver

Reviewed by Meagan
Published: 1988
It's about: Marietta Greer was born and raised in rural Kentucky, but her plan is to get out as soon as she can. Unlike most of the girls her age, she avoids getting pregnant, gets herself a good job, and finally saves up enough money to buy an old VW Bug. She hits the road, changes her name to "Taylor" after one of the towns she passes through, and proceeds to drive across the country.
The car is, of course, unreliable, and through a series of breakdowns, Taylor's life is changed forever. In the Cherokee Nation in Oklahoma, she is given a young toddler girl by a woman claiming to be the child's aunt. Not knowing what else to do, Taylor takes her on the road. She discovers the girl (whom she names "Turtle" because of her penchant for grabbing at anything within her reach) has been abused and become fiercely protective of her.
The two eventually break down in Tuscon, Arizona and begin to build a life and create a family of characters including another Kentucky transplant, the female owner of the Jesus is Lord Used Tires store, and a Guatemalan couple seeking political asylum. Together this unexpected group explores themes of family, life, death, beauty, friendship, hope, and love.

I thought: In all honesty, I was a little underwhelmed by this book. I didn't know at the time I read this that it was Barbara Kingsolvers's first book, and had I known that, I might have been a little less critical when comparing this novel to her other works. You can definitely see the seeds of future greatness here, but they haven't blossomed yet. The story was mildly entertaining, and there were some interesting issues explored, but overall I felt it was patched together a little roughly and there was inexplicably too much going on while nothing really happened. (I know that doesn't make a lot of sense but maybe if you read it it will?).
Verdict: Stick it on the shelf or Rubbish Bin? Rubbish Bin. I feel bad saying that, but I definitely didn't find it shelf worthy and don't feel the need to ever revisit it. Maybe read it if you want to see Kingsolver at the start of her career.  I didn't feel like it was a waste of time to read it, but I would definitely recommend almost every other Kingsolver book to this one

Reading Recommendations: None.
Warnings: There are a few thematic elements of abuse, but nothing overt or graphic.
Favorite excerpts:
"There was a cactus with bushy arms and a coat of yellow spines as thick as fur. A bird had built her nest in it. In and out she flew among the horrible spiny branches, never once hesitating. You just couldn't imagine how she'd made a home in there."

"Hughes Walter was no Kentucky boy. He was from out of state, from some city college up north, which was why, everyone presumed, his name was backwards."

"To keep ourselves from going crazy with boredom we tried to think of word games. I told about the secretary named Jewel with the son who sees things backwards, and we tried to think of words he would like. Esperanza though of ala, which means wing. Estevan knew whole sentences, some in Spanish and some in English. The English ones were "A man, a plan, a canal: Panama!" (which he said was a typical gringo way of looking at that endeavor), and "Able was I ere I saw Elba," which was what Napoleon supposedly said when he was sent into exile. I hadn't known, before then, where or what Elba was. I'd had a vague idea that it was a kind of toast."

What I'm reading next: I Am The Messenger by Marcus Zusak

Comments (8)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I felt similarly about this book. I read it not long after reading The Poisonwood Diaries (which I loved). I found that the writing didn't even feel the same, it felt younger and less...poetic (if that's the right world). There just didn't seem to be anything of substance here.
1 reply · active 706 weeks ago
You've hit on it exactly!
Whaaaaat??? I LOVE The Bean Trees! I've actually read it twice (which is saying something, since I hardly ever reread) and I find it understated and beautiful. She avoids the overt preachiness of her later books but still gives the reader an important issue or two to think about. I think the characters are memorable and likeable. Her writing (as always) is excellent- original and poignant. I like that it is small and simply told- of course it's not a masterpiece like Poisonwood or Lacuna, but more of a sweet, smart story.
I'm so sorry you didn't like it! Maybe I talked it up too much- I think I've left a couple of comments here and there about how much I like it, and I know that can be counter-productive sometimes.
1 reply · active 706 weeks ago
Ha ha. I do remember you mentioning how much you liked it before. Maybe you should write a counter review!

I do agree that it is very understated and a sweet, smart story. In fact, I'm pretty sure I did give a little contented sigh as I closed the book. I think the problem is that it didn't have a lot of staying power and I am more in favor of books that stay with me long after I finish the story.

If it makes you feel any better, I'm not a huge fan of her writing in general. It is, as you say, excellent, but the style is just not exactly my cup of tea.
I actually loved this book! I do tend to enjoy books that are short on plot but strong on characters, which certainly isn't for everyone. I thought this book had one of the most satisfying endings I have ever read.
1 reply · active 706 weeks ago
I'm with you, Lorren! Have you read the sequel, Pigs in Heaven? It's not as good as The Bean Trees, but still worth a read.
I read this after my sister claimed it was her favorite book, but I was also underwhelmed. I may have never mentioned that I read it to her. I never made it very far in The Poisonwood Bible, liked Prodigal Summer okay, but liked her memoir Animal, Vegetable, Mineral the most because it inspired me to start gardening.
I also really enjoyed this book, or I would never have continued reading her. But I read Kingssolver in order, so I was able to see her evolution as an author. And unlike most people, I did NOT love Poisonwood Bible. I think that Prodigal Summer is actually her best book. I also really enjoyed The Lacuna.

Post a new comment

Comments by