Monday, April 30, 2012

April Classics Challenge: Book Covers



Posted by Connie

It's been a little while since we've posted for the Classics Challenge, but I decided to jump back into it this month. Lately, I have been chipping away at Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina, and since I'm in the midst of moving, it's taking me longer than usual, and it's also the only thing I have time to read. Hence my lack of reviews.

Enough disclaimers. On to the discussion. The questions for this month are:
  • What are your first impressions of the cover?
  • Does the cover reflect the character, setting, or plot?
  • If you designed a book cover, what would you have chosen?
Anna Karenina has been released so many times, so it has had many a cover. Here's the one I'm reading (since this is the translation Ingrid recommended):

I am about 65% through the book, so I cannot definitively say this, but thus far, I do not remember an instance when any character has bare legs and holds some flowers dramatically between them. So unless that comes later (and who knows, perhaps it does), I'm thinking this is not meant to be a literal representation of any particular event in the book.

So let's look at it in the abstract. The legs are bare, and though nowadays women parade around in super-mini-skirts, such was not the fashion among high society in 1870s Russia. So between the nakedness of the legs and the flowers, it could be alluding to Anna's affair with Vronsky (her "de-flowering", if you want to get vulgar), or even more abstractly, the loss of her innocence. Also, the purples are in color while everything else is in black and white, making for an overall dramatic and tragic feel -- perfectly fitting the story of Anna Karenin.

Man, I had to pick a hard cover, didn't I? Other Anna Karenina covers would have been a lot more obvious, like these:
 Anna is so sad that she's ruining her life, so she lies dramatically on the chaise.
Anna is beautiful and high society but oh so sad and tragic, so she leans on the table to keep from fainting from the sadness and tragedy of it all.
Anna Karenina is a modern, haute couture model trying desperately to get her picture on the cover of Marie Claire.











All right, you Anna Karenina fans out there, what do you make of the flowers and legs cover?

Comments (12)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
That cover always confused me! I thought it was a picture of a butt at first ... it took me awhile to realize that it was knees.
HAHA. I'm glad I'm not the only one. I read this book again for a Tolstoy class in college and they all thought I was crazy when I said I thought it looked like a butt. Someone else thought it was a shoulder and someone thought it was grave stones, but no one else saw the butt.
I actually thought it was a butt, too, when I first saw it, but that would be a really loooooong, oddly shaped butt.
I always thought that top one was a shoulder shot reflected in a mirror!!

Okay... now it occurs to me the shoulder model is missing a head...
Oh they're KNEES! I thought either boobs or bum, but knees didn't occur to me! Hmm... now what could flowers clenched between knees have to do with Anna Karenina? Give me a minute, I'm sure something will come to me.....

Could it be an agricultural reference? After all, Levin's got a farm and he's very interested in agricultural reform - perhaps the flowers represent the harvest and they're clenched between bare peasant knees that can't afford clothes....? ;-)
1 reply · active 675 weeks ago
Haha I love your comments on the other covers. Especially about the cover of Marie Claire. Haha anyway the knee/butt/shoulder & flowers is the cover I have. Except mine had this little Oprah's book club selection thing as part of it but I took it off because it embarrassed me.
I thought is was a visual representation of her time spent in the home for sisters of austere faith, in which they garden in the buff as part of their renunciation of all things material.
1 reply · active 675 weeks ago
Ah! Very possibly. I haven't reached that part, yet. As I said, for all I know there IS a part coming up in which she holds flowers dramatically between bare legs. Whaddya know??
lol! I love your humor with the other covers. My favorite is the 'Anna is beautiful and high society but oh so sad and tragic, so she leans on the table to keep from fainting from the sadness and tragedy of it all.' :) Thanks for participating, Connie!
I haven't had 'courage' to read Anna Karenina until now, how do you think of the story?
About the cover, I can't guess what it is before reading your post.. But I prefer the wordsworth edition, it feels more 'classics'.

Post a new comment

Comments by