Monday, October 18, 2010

Review: Little Women by Louisa May Alcott

Reviewed by Ingrid

Published: 1869

It's about: Little Women follows the exploits and antics of the March sisters - Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy. In Part 1 their father has gone to fight in the Civil War, and the March family is "poor," though they live in Concord, Massachusetts, have a comfortable house, a servant who cooks them all kinds of delicious meals, and a few cuddly kittens. Despite the "hardships" of their poverty, the girls find any and every opportunity to provide charitable acts to others. The girls also make friends with Theodore Laurence, better known as Laurie, the feisty little boy next door who eventually falls in love with Jo. The March sisters get in all kinds of little troubles, though they know they can always turn to their beloved mother, otherwise known as Marmee, for love and advice. In Part 2 the girls meet their husbands, get married, and create their own respective domestic paradises. Oh and Jo finally gets published.

I thought: This book was pretty much just as I expected it to be. The girls learn all kinds of "lessons" as a result of various behaviors, which I admit, got way old after a short while. The book had a clear didactic streak and is very sentimental. There are many thrilling sewing scenes and learning to respect one's husband.  I understand that this book was written for children, and I think if I was younger I would have enjoyed it more. To sum up, this book didn't do much for me.

Verdict: I'm going to say this one is a definite in-betweener.

Reading Recommendations: If you are an ~10 year old girl, you will love it. If you are older and have good childhood memories of the book or movie, you may also love it. For me, I think just the movie would have sufficed.

Warnings: Watch out - lots of sappy, sweet familial/domestic love-y parts. 

Favorite excerpts: "Mrs. March glanced at Meg, who was looking very pretty in her gingham morning gown, with the little curls blowing about her forehead, and very womanly, as she sat sewing at her little worktable, full of tidy white rolls, so unconscious of the thought in her mother's mind as she sewed and sang, while her fingers flew and her thoughts were busied with girlish fancies as innocent and fresh as the pansies in her belt, that Mrs. March smiled and was satisfied."

*** On Thursday I will be reviewing March by Geraldine Brooks, which tells the story of the Little Women's father and his war experiences.

Comments (10)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I love this book. I read it first as a child so that's probably why I still love it so much. Did you read the American or the British version? I'm British and the British version is split into two halves (Little Women & Good Wives) - I love Little Women but did not enjoy Good Wives much at all.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Hi Sam. I read the American version -- it has two parts as well, but they are both under the title of Little Women. I think I liked the first part much better as well.
I agree about the excessive sentimentality of the book. I did read it when I was younger, and I remember thinking that even then...
Oh no! I adored this book! I just finished it a couple weeks ago.

All that sentimentality - not Alcott's idea! ;-)

I added a couple of the books that follow this one (Joy's Boys, Little Men) to my list, because I love this one so much. One of my favorites. :-)
1 reply · active 754 weeks ago
Hi Jill. Haha, actually, I read your review when you posted it a few weeks ago and referred to it a few times when I was reading the book. I thought it was an excellent review. I have an extremely low threshold for anything that strikes me as sentimental, which is why this book wasn't as ... how do you say ... palatable to me.
Thanks for stopping by!
BookQuoter's avatar

BookQuoter · 754 weeks ago

This is a book I am rereading, very soon!!
Hi, visiting from Lori's Linky.
Little Women was a favourite of mine growing up!
www.bookdout.wordpress.com
Thanks for the honest review.

I tried to read this several times as a child but kept giving up. I will however try to read this again soon to see if I can finally get through it as an adult.
I know I had a copy of this book when I was a kid, but I can't for the life of me remember if I actually read it! I keep telling myself I should, but it really does sound like a book to be read when you're younger.
I haven't tried reading this book! I will in the future! Thanks for the review, dear!

Post a new comment

Comments by