Saturday, October 23, 2010

The Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd


For those of you from the Blog Hop, come visit our Blog Hop post.


Reviewed by Lucia

Published: 2002

It's about: Fourteen year old Lily Owens has spent her life peach farming with her aggressive and unforgiving father in South Carolina. Suffocated by the belief that she accidentally shot her mother as a child, Lily feels unworthy of love, although with her sole friend being Rosaleen (a black housekeeper), it is the only thing she yearns for. Now in the early 1960's, an explosive event makes Lily aware of the true hatred stirred by racial prejudice. When she and Rosaleen escape, they end up tracing the faint past of Lily's mother, leading them to the pink house of Black Madonna Honey.

I thought: I have hesitated many times in picking up this book, there having been so much hype. I was even more tentative about reviewing it, but in fact I couldn't resist. The Secret Life of Bees is eccentric, sharp, funny, unforgiving, unique and delightfully charming. Narrated by a young girl, Monk Kidd is able force her point through blunt statements whilst still creating an exceptionally original plot and engaging characters.

I really loved the sections about bees. Honestly I never thought I could be so drawn in by the life of insects but I found myself truly interested in how the honey was produced and how the Calendar Sisters went about beekeeping in general. It was wonderful to be shown that in such a disgusting world the author created a character like Lily, who has never felt loved but is capable of sending love to even the tiniest creatures that are bees.

Whilst I enjoyed Monk Kidd's writing style, I felt that in some places it could have been embellished a little more. Yet this is just personal opinion and the language was appropriate for the overall off beat atmosphere of the novel. The way in which Lily's feelings and thoughts were described seemed to be painted more realistically than much of her physical surroundings, and I was intrigued by this. I felt that it reflected the girl's understanding of the world and her place in it.

Verdict: Stick it on the shelf.

Reading Recommendations: Of course a film has now been made based on this book. I highly recommend reading the book first because I think many details were lost in the film. It isn't a bad adaptation though, and as usual Dakota Fanning is a stand out.

Warnings: None.

Favorite excerpts: 'The problem is they know what matters, but they don't choose it. You know how hard that is Lily? I love May, but it was still so hard to choose Carribbean Pink. The hardest thing on earth is choosing what matters.'

'A sound rushed up. A perfect hum, high-pitched and swollen, like someone had put the teakettle on and it had come to a boil. 'They're cooling the hives down,' she said...You would have to hear it yourself to believe the perfect pitch, the harmony parts, how the volume rolled up and down. We had our ears pressed to a giant music box.'

Comments (19)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I have this on my shelf waiting to be read. I just read The Help so might wait awhile before reading another book set in the South, but I do intend to read it soon.
I have this book laying around somewhere and I've been wanting to read it but totally forgot about it! Really like your review of it and now I want to find the book and stick it in my soon-to-read stack :)
I really want to read this book!
I know I'm in the minority here, but I didn't particularly like this book when I read it a few years ago. I felt like it was a little fluffy and sentimental in regard to the important questions raised by the setting; the author brought up a bunch of issues and then didn't take them anywhere. Of course, I don't remember details now, and I know those kind of generalizations aren't helpful. My opinion may also be tainted by the only other book I've read by Sue Monk Kidd, The Mermaid Chair, which I thought was downright crappy.
Uh... sorry to be such a naysayer! I know several people whose opinions I respect who loved this book, so it could be that I was just cranky when I read it?
8 replies · active 752 weeks ago
Christina, did you read The Help? I haven't but, considering what you say about The Secret Life of Bees I'd be interested to know what you would say about The Help.
I haven't read The Help yet. I've heard/read lots of rave reviews, and I enjoyed an interview with Kathryn Stockett on NPR a while back. Maybe I'll snatch my mom-in-law's copy when I visit her at Thanksgiving.
Meagan, have you read The Help? It'd be interesting to see a sort of side-by-side comparison with The Secret Life of Bees.
I've heard so many things about it too ... good and bad. My mom hated it, haha. Her reasoning was similar to why you did like TSLOB, Christina. I would love to see a side-by-side comparison as well.
Erm, Lucia, not Meagan. Sorry!
But I was glad to hear from you, too! Have you seen the movie adaptation of The Secret Life of Bees?
I picked this book up about three years ago when I heard they were making a movie (I usually try and read books before I see movies, I also agree that a lot of details get lost in the trim to film). I got about halfway through it before I had to turn it back in and I honestly wasn't impressed by it enough to ever finish it. Your review does make me want to give it another try though.____And yes Christina, I have read The Help. It's phenomenal and is actually on my list of books I'd like to review here. Having not finished The Secret Life Of Bees I wouldn't be able to do a side-by-side comparison but it would be another perspective on the genre. Should I move it to the top of the list?
I've never heard of The Help, but it seems that I am the only one! I would say yes, Meagan, bump it up to the top of your list!!!
Haha, Christina's comment made me laugh. Thanks for reviewing this Lucia, I read "The Dance of the Dissident Daughter" (a "spiritual memoir") by Sue Monk Kidd and I've always been curious about what her fiction is like. I know Connie really liked The Secret Life of Bees and The Mermaid Chair.
1 reply · active 753 weeks ago
Yes, I did really enjoy both of those novels, but like Christina, I read them quite a while ago, so I don't remember many details as to opening themes and not closing them. I just remember really enjoying them.

As to The Mermaid Chair, it was one of those books that I was sort of enjoying it throughout, but from the beginning, I knew that the ending would make it or break it for me. I ended up liking the ending, so I liked the book.

I'd have to reread both of those books to have a more in-depth discussion about them, though.
Probably not just cranky Christina! I did notice that Monk Kidd seemed to introduce several themes and not see them through. I think the reason this didn't bother me was that I have very little knowledge about the historical setting of this book (in fact nothing more than I got from To Kill A Mockingbird), not being from the US. I haven't read The Help but have heard worlds about it and it seems interesting. Thanks for the thoughts!
You are cordially invited to add a link to your book reviews for the week at my Saturday Review of Books at Semicolon. It's a sort of round-up of bloggers' book reviews each week on Saturday: http://www.semicolonblog.com/?p=11766
I remember liking this book when I read it back in middle school, but when I go back to think of it I feel like it might be a little too rosy and sentimental. I remember being especially intrigued by the idea of the female divine that was brought up at the end of the book. I don't really buy into it much now, but when I read it the idea had never even crossed my mind so I found it quite shocking. I remember some people in another discussion noting that this book played into certain racial stereotypes, with the black characters simply serving as a way for the main character to grow rather than being real people. I definitely think more character development could have happened, and I definitely agree that she left some ends that needed to be tied up. All that said, I really liked it when I read it, and as long as I read it again I'll always have good memories of it.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I, too, read this when I was younger and probably a little more tolerant of the sentimental. I could see the argument about the characters functioning as catalysts for her growth, but... is that so bad? Do we live in such an age of realist literature that we cannot appreciate symbolic literature? It's an interesting thought.
I loved your review and l loved this novel. I read this over a lovely holiday that I was having last year and I always remember it. I saw the movie recently. It is not a bad take on the events in the book. This novel has a permanent place on my shelf.

Post a new comment

Comments by