Thursday, November 11, 2010

Literary Blog Hop: Nov 11-14

Welcome to this week's Literary Blog Hop hosted by The Blue Bookcase!

This blog hop is open to blogs that primarily feature book reviews of literary fiction, classic literature, and general literary discussion. If your blog does not fit this description, it may be removed from the Linky List. 

How do I know if my blog qualifies as "literary"? Literature has many definitions, but for our purposes your blog qualifies as "literary" if it focuses primarily on texts with aesthetic merit. In other words, texts that show quality not only in narrative but also in the effect of their language and structure. YA literature may fit into this category, but if your blog focuses primarily on non-literary YA, fantasy, romance, paranormal romance, or chick lit, you may prefer to join the blog hop at Crazy-for-books that is open to book blogs of all genres.

Instructions for entering the Literary Blog Hop:


1. Grab the code for the Button.


Literary Blog Hop
2. Answer the following prompt on your blog:


This week's question comes from Debbie Nance at Readerbuzz
What is the most difficult literary work you've ever read? What made it so difficult?

(Suggestions for future prompts? Email them to us at thebluebookcase@gmail.com)


Our answer this week comes from Ingrid:

The most difficult literary work I've ever read was probably Doctor Faustus by Thomas Mann. The reason that this book was so difficult is primarily because it has five "themes" going on at once. The first is the surface story, which is about a German composer named Adrian Leverkühn who contracts syphilus on purpose in order to fuel his creativity and write his greatest piece of music. This story parallels the traditional German Faust legend, with Adrian as the Faust figure, as he makes a sort of "pact" with the devil in that he gives himself over to the disease to be able to become a better composer. Adrian's story also runs parallel to the life of the notoriously anti-Christian philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche down to the smallest details. The story also contains important references to music theory, mentioning certain notes at key points in the story that all work together to create a resonant "chord." Lastly, this novel also acts as a metaphor commenting on the politics in Germany leading up to World War Two, essentially suggesting that Germany is also making a pact with a "devil." Besides the surface narrative itself, these other themes are veiled and not mentioned directly. Readers would miss out on this novel's incredible amplitude and depth of its message without recognizing the allusions and understanding the significant relationship between traditional German folklore, Friedrich Nietzsche, music theory, and pre-World War Two Germany. Luckily, I read this book in a class was able to study it in depth ... otherwise I certainly would not have appreciated the absolute genius that is Thomas Mann. This book also contains the most powerful and resonant last line I have probably ever read. So there you go, the most difficult literary work I have ever read!

3. Put your link and the name of your blog in the Mr. Linky below. 

4. Visit the blogs in the list and leave a comment. Thanks for participating!

Comments (68)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
This is a great discussion meme. Thanks for hosting.

Charlie
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
I am really glad you started this event-I answered this weeks question and also proposed another related question-what was the most difficult book you ever loved and how did its difficulty contribute to the works power for you-my answer is in my post for this weeks hop
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Thank you for continuing this hop!
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Great question again this week! I've never read Thomas Mann but I'm glad that, despite the book's difficulty, in the end you were glad you read it.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
I have a great contender. A mountain of frustration...and not that rewarding of a novel.
Great question. And unlike a "what's the best book you've ever read" question that would cause me great anxiety, I had no trouble answering this one!
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Guys, I gave the wrong link:
http://www.deadendfollies.com/2010/11/literary-bl...

here's the right one.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
I've added it, but I'm not sure it worked?
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Yes, it just took time somehow. :O)

I'm a happy camper. I love the hop
I already want to change my answer, because I forgot how much I hated Rob Roy. :)
I've never read anything by Thomas Mann but this certainly does seem like a difficult literary book to read! However interesting, nonetheless. You've intrigued me to pick up a copy.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Thomas Mann knocked the hell out of me with The Magic Mountain. I have no doubt that Dr. Faustus is horribly complex and I have no desire to find out whether it's true or not.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Okay, now I must find out what that last line is!

Thank you for sharing your review of this book.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
nice question! i am really enjoying this meme so far.

and side note - my internet went a little funny and somehow i was jumped down to the last blog hop linky while halfway through typing in and completed and submitted the form there, too, before realizing what went on. how do these things happen? such potentially useful shortcuts i find while hitting the wrong keys on my keyboard...
Great question, and I am really liking this blog hop!
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Thanks for hosting this hop!

From your description I'm thinking it would take me somewhere around 10 readings to really understand all of the facets of this book. Though it sounds interesting so I may give it a try.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
What you say about Dr. Faustus captures the difference between "literary" and popular fiction: there are five themes interwoven into the plot, the notes introduced at different plot points add up to a final chord....a perfect example of the level of complexity readers may find either very challenging, very satisfying--or both!
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Great question! Thanks Debnance. Glad to see there is a good following for the hop. And that Thomas Mann book sounds like it's right up my street.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
This is a great way to see blogs I've never been introduced to before. What a fun question to think about and answer!
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Funny enough, I never finished Doctor Faustus because I realized I was missing so much. I loved The Magic Mountain, even read it a second time. But I could not get my mind around Faustus and all that was going on. Wish I'd found some helpful notes on it way back when. It's been about 30 years, I should try it again. Thanks for reminding me about this book-and for your honesty.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
Great answer! I plan to read Thomas Mann this winter, but I'll be starting with Buddenbrooks. Will add both Doctor Faustus and The Magic Mountain to my list.
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
I'm totally cheating by leaving my Literary Blog Post up from last week--but for anyone that's interested, I think Ulysses is definitely the most difficult work I've ever read, though I had to put down Infinite Jest earlier this year because I thought the footnotes would drive me insane (sorry, Greg). Also, Don DeLillo's Cosmopolis comes close because it is the absolute worst piece of trash I have ever read and every word of it was pure torture. Happy weekend everyone.
2 replies · active 752 weeks ago
I'd love to post this weekly event over at A Novel Challenge ( http://novelchallenges.blogspot.com/ )...could you tell me which day of the week you generally post the prompt? thanks!
2 replies · active 752 weeks ago
Oh a wonderful topic! Let me think some about this before I post the discussion and answer on my blog!
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago
wooo new hopper! love this :)
1 reply · active 752 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by