Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Top Ten Six Tuesday: LIES

Oh, yes. Lying. We all do it. Some of us might even enjoy it just a little bit sometimes. Lying is actually one of my favorite ideas- so much so that I wrote a whole post about lying and literature a couple of months ago. I'm reeeeally looking forward to hopping around and reading everyone's dirty little secret lies.
But the problem is that I don't lie about books very often. And when I do, it's usually to protect the feelings of the person who recommended the book to me, y'knowhaI'msayin'? So if I come clean with those lies and those people read this post... then I look like a liar AND a jerky snob who didn't like that favorite book you recommended.
Tricky, tricky prompt, Broke and Bookish writers. But I'll do my best to come up with some answers while (hopefully) managing to not alienate my friends. Here goes!

1. The Southern Vampire Mysteries, by Charlaine Harris
Ooooookay. This was the first thing to come to mind because I've been watching the third season of True Blood lately and so I have Sookie and Bill on the brain. And really, I like the campy, b-movie-ish HBO adaptation better than the novels. But I can't deny that I was pretty into these books (I read the first two and then stopped because I didn't want to know where the show would be going in future seasons) and I don't think I ever expressed that. So the lie was that I didn't like them. I did! (Don't tell my mother.)

2. Mrs. Mike by Benedict and Nancy Freedman
I read this for a book club in which, like most book clubs, we all took turns choosing a book. This was the favorite book of the chooser for that particular month, and when we met to discuss it I was too shy (and considerate, I guess) to speak openly about how trite I thought it was. It's like the writers took a fascinating life story, wrote it poorly, and stuffed it full of cutesy life lessons. UGH.
Come to think of it, I could probably compose an entire Top 10 list of books I read for various book clubs that I tempered my attitude toward in order to save somebody else's feelings.

3. Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë
Alrighty, here's a juicy lie: I have never read the ending of Jane Eyre. Can you believe it? I consider it a book I like, even love, and yet when I read it in high school I stopped about fifty pages short of the end. Why didn't I finish it? I don't remember exactly, but it could have had something to do with my desire to be a rebel. Maybe I didn't finish it (even though I liked it) just because I disliked the feeling that I had to read it for school. Yeah, sort of a stupid way to stick it to the man. I've learned the ending from watching multiple adaptations, and since I don't generally reread books I'm not sure I'll ever be able to count myself among true fans of Jane Eyre.

4. Snow White and Sleeping Beauty picture books
When I was at a garage sale with my daughter on Saturday, she picked out these two princess books and said, "Mommy! Look what I found!" I glanced down and said something like "Great, honey! I love those!" I generally try to match her enthusiasm level when I can. But in this case I could have kicked myself because that was a total lie. Those two pitiful victims are definitely not my favorite princesses, and picture book versions of Disney classics tend to be poorly written, watered-down substitutes for the movies.

5. The Girls' Guide to Hunting and Fishing by Melissa Bank
In college there was a brief period where I was sorta seeing this cool boy. He was a super smart violist who was composing a ballet. He wore awesome Danish shoes. He lent me this book because he thought I would like it, so I read it. But alas, it was sorta boring and difficult for me to relate to. I can't actually remember anything about it now (years later) except the disappointing "meh" feeling I had when I finished. Of course, when I returned it to him I told him I liked it. Lie! And a pointless one at that.

6. Most Shakespeare plays
Yeah, I'm continually pretending to be more familiar with Shakespeare than I really am. I'm like a boss when it comes to Hamlet and Romeo and Juliet, but I've never read Othello or King Lear or Macbeth. And when those plays or their characters come up in conversation I somehow still think I can wing it and pretend I know what everyone's talking about. It doesn't really work.


Uh... I'm stuck! I can't think of any other books I've lied about! I'll edit this if I come up with more. Have you ever lied about books? Which ones?

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I find it really interesting that you liked Jane Eyre but never finished it. I have to really hate a book not to finish it, to not finish one I really liked would take more control than I have!
1 reply · active 723 weeks ago
I know exactly what you mean! I hardly ever stop reading books now, even if I really hate them. But ten years ago I was a different person, totally willing to hurt myself to make a point.
I've never read a book by Charlene Harris. I've kind of wanted to, but they're never in when I go to the library and my desire to read them isn't strong enough to ask for one to be reserved for me. I know it's awful of me to think it's hilarious that you lied about the disney princesses but I did. I kind of can't believe you stopped Jane Eyre 50 pages from the end. That's so close!! So I think it's safe to call yourself a true fan. :) Alot of the ones on my list are ones I had to read for school as well. Great list though!
2 replies · active 723 weeks ago
Thanks! The Sookie Stackhouse books are worth checking out sometime when you want something really fluffy (and kinda lusty and bloody) but they're not wonderful or anything.
Aaaaand I just read your list, but I can't comment (Blogger hates me today?) so I just wanted to tell you that it made me laugh! Great lies. I've never read The Secret, but I was coerced into watching the DVD and I FREAKING HATE THE WHOLE PREMISE. But then, I'm a cranky skeptic who knocks all things inspirational. So I would recommend continuing to lie about reading it. :)
Most of mine were books I didn't read that were prescribed for class but I also had one where I didn't read a book a friend gifted me and lied and said I had and I liked it.
Awesome, list, Christina -- way to come clean. So you probably never finished Jane Eyre because once Jane leaves Mr. Rochester and is wandering around in the wilderness, the book hits this BRICK WALL, and it becomes almost unbearable to keep reading. Even once she finds Sir John and them, it completely messes up the flow of the book, and you're like, wait, is this book starting over? What happened to the plot that drove the LAST 800 pages??
Jane Eyre just intimidates me. I don't know if I'll ever read it or not.
Oh gosh, I'd say I've faked reading Shakespeare and pretend to know more that I do. My secret is the No Fear Shakespeare books hidden in the back of Barnes and Noble. No teacher wants you to know about them. And I too have never finished reading Jane Eyre.
1 reply · active 723 weeks ago
Whaaaaat? I need to find these No Fear Shakespeare books so I can stop being embarrassed about my lack of knowledge! They sound awesome! Thanks for the heads-up. :)
I couldn't find books about which I have lied....
http://readbookswritepoetry.blogspot.com/2011/05/...
I should have put Sookie Stackhouse on my list too - I totally forgot about them. LOL

great list! Stop by and see mine! http://www.memyshelfandi.com/2011/05/top-ten-tues...
I'm with you on the Disney version fairy tales--I wish I'd never read them, but alas I have 4 daughters and 3 grandaughters so I had to get through them.

I read Mrs Mike--I'm one of those that liked it (I will not lie)

AND I'm so shocked you didn't read to the end of Jane Eyre! You really must, it's the best part.
1 reply · active 723 weeks ago
Yeah, I guess princesses are just something that mothers of daughters have to put up with for a while.
I think I probably will revisit Jane Eyre someday, though I already know the ending from seeing a bzillion movie and TV adaptations.
Hahaha. Number 5 sounds like something I would do. I always would read certain books to try to impress boys.
2 replies · active 723 weeks ago
I feel so out of the loop. I don't think I've ever read a book to impress a boy... watched a movie to impress them, sure, gotten into a band to impress them, but maybe I just didn't date bookish boys.

AH! Wait. I did read one. Phew, okay, we're cool.
Wait. Gotten into a band to impress a boy?? That sounds like a story worth telling!
Tempered, yes. Lied, no. Really. I'm being honest.

Hope you'll stop by my blog: Readerbuzz. Not much there this week, but maybe, if you browse a bit, you will find something else of interest. And I do have a great giveaway going on....
It was surprisingly easy for me to come up with these. I haven't ever finished Jane Eyre either and it feels good to admit it.

Come check out The Scarlet Letter's Top Ten Tuesday
+JMJ+

Lying to little kids to get them to read? Yeah, I do the same thing! LOL! ;-)

I always tell myself, "This just brings them one step closer to the proficiency it takes to appreciate the classics!"

But I think I'd draw the line at "Disney books." There's something stultifying about a book based on a movie based on a book.

Post a new comment

Comments by