Monday, September 26, 2011

Review: A Moveable Feast by Ernest Hemingway

Reviewed by Ingrid

Published: 1964

It's about: This is a memoir about Hemingway's time spent in Paris in the 1920s. In his typical sparse, straighforward style he describes his daily writing habits, his friendships with famous writers like Gertrude Stein and F. Scott Fitzgerald, and his adventures living in poverty with his first wife, Hadley.

Me at one of Hemingway's
 favorite hangouts in 2009
I thought: Woo! Loved it, just like I thought it would. It's extremely refreshing to read such a straightforward, delightfully simple memoir. You don't get those too often. Honestly, Hemingways could write about something as boring as sitting in a chair and staring at a wall in a way that makes it seem so lovely and meaningful. He makes being poor sound fun. Amazing!

Hemingway's descriptions of his time spent with F. Scott Fitzerald and his antics are HILARIOUS. My favorite line from this part is when they are in a hotel together and Scott dramatically insists he is sick. Hemingway writes:

Back in the room Scott was still lying as though on his tomb, sculpted as a monument to himself, his eyes closed and breathing with exemplary dignity.

Hadley and Ernest Hemingway,
 winter in Switzerland 1922 (via)

HA HA! Sculpted as a monument to himself. How perfect is that line???

I also really loved the very end of the book about Hemingway and Hadley's time spent skiing in Switzerland. It really, really made me want to go skiing. Come on, snow!

Verdict: Stick it on the shelf.

Reading Recommendations: I've heard that a great companion read to this book is The Paris Wife, written from Hadley's point of view. Also, if you read this book first I guarantee that you will love the movie Midnight in Paris.

Warnings: Drinking. Lots of drinking. Hemingway writes about it in a way that makes you want to drink a lot, too. But don't. That's not healthy.

Favorite excerpts: "That afternoon she [Gertrude Stein] told us, too, how to buy pictures.
   'You can either buy clothes or buy pictures,' she said. 'It's that simple. No one who is not very rich can do both. Pay no attention to your clothes and no attention at all to the mode, and buy your clothes for comfort and durability, and you will have the clothes money to buy pictures.'
   'But even if I never bought any more clothing ever,' I said, 'I wouldn't have enough money to buy the Picassos that I want.'
   'No. He's out of your range. You have to buy the people of your own age--of your own military service group. You'll know them. You'll meet them around the quarter. There are always good new serious painters. But it's not you buying clothes so much. It's your wife always. It's women's clothes that are expensive.'
   I saw my wife trying not to look at the strange, steerage clothes that Miss Stein wore and she was successful."

What I'm reading next: Almost done with Jude the Obscure

Comments (19)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I love Hemingway's writing. I also agree that it was refreshing to read this book - I mentioned in my review for this book last year that if it's black, it's black, if it's white, it's white. Hemingway doesn't deal in the in-between with this book - everything is straight-forward. Loved this book and I wish I had read it much sooner.
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Yes, I love his straightforwardness in this book. Very refreshing. It really worked in this memoir. But in some of his other works I find his writing just kind of ... boring. (Hello Old Man and the Sea ....)
This is one of my favorite books ever! Your review is bang-on. One of my favorite excerpts is the part where he is describing the goatherd coming down the street in the early morning and then stopping in front of their apartment to fill his neighbor's bucket with goat milk. It was such a sweet little vignette.

I was fortunate to be able to go to Paris this past spring, even with a stop at Shakespeare and Company. This book was on my mind the whole time!

I'm looking forward to reading The Paris Wife and watching Midnight in Paris, too.
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Yess! I'm so glad you loved it too. I remember that goat milk part - there are so many little side stories and descriptions like that throughout the book that I just loved. Midnight in Paris is hilarious, you have to see it ASAP!
I am no fan of Hemingway or his fiction, but this is a book that I liked very much, quite to my surprise!
2 replies · active 704 weeks ago
Ahaha. Yes, I have some reservations about him and his work as well. Not a huge fan of The Old Man and the Sea or A Farewell to Arms - the only other works of his that I've read. This one, however, I loved.
A Farewell to Arms is my favorite of his, and I liked Old Man and the Sea as well.. I also liked For Whom the Bell Tolls and absolutely LOVED The Garden of Eden. I did not, however, like The Sun Also Rises. At all. That's supposed to be "the one" book for so many... but it was just.. geh.
Sounds like a great book. I haven't read anything by Hemingway yet, would you recommend this one as a first read or would you recommend to start with one of his other novels or short story collections first?
2 replies · active 704 weeks ago
Hmm ... good question. If I were you I think I would start with some of his short stories. Actually, Hemingway is kind of interesting because a lot of people react very negatively to some of his writing and then love other of his writing, so I would definitely say that you should try a few of his works, even if you don't like what you read first. I think one of the major problems with him is his attitude towards women in life and his kind of shallow depictions of them in his work. If that puts you off, I would say you will probably really like A Moveable Feast but probably not like a lot of his other well known stuff, like A Farewell to Arms.
Okay thanks for that. I'll make sure I try a couple of things before I decide an overall opinion on his writing.
I read in the opposite direction you did. I read The Paris Wife - which I enjoyed and reviewed on my blog - and it made me want to read A Moveable Feast. Thanks for the review; it was the extra push I needed. I'll be picking it up soon.
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Cool, well I hope you like it! I'm sure you will - it's a difficult book not to like.
I found your site when clicking through on other sites. And what a coincidence because just yesterday I finished reading The Paris Wife. I heartily recommend that book because it gives voice to the woman who was both a constant presence in Hemingway's memoir and without a voice of her own. I picked up Moveable Feast before heading back to France and found it was the only Hemingway book that I loved without reservation. In fact, it made me almost want to go back and read the books I thought were torture in college. We shall see.
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Yes, it seems that a lot of people who don't necessarily like Hemingway's other work always love this one. Isn't that funny? And wow, it looks like I really need to read The Paris Wife - I feel like the only one who hasn't read it now!
I really dug the nature of his relationships to Ezra Pound and Fitzgerald. He's kinda protective of pound and I like that.
I just read this one too and even though I'm not a fan of Hemingway, I really liked it. Loved the quote, I thought Stein had a lot of nerve to dictate how they spent their money!
1 reply · active 704 weeks ago
Stein was THE BOSS.
I have been looking forward to your review of this! I have been interested in it, but I have avoided it as I am not a huge Hemingway fan from the books of his that I have read. Although that was several years ago, so I should perhaps give him another shot? Eh, let's be honest -- it's not going to happen any time soon.
Yay, Hemingway! Actually, he's hit-or-miss for me.. but I tend to like him more often than not.

Have you read The Torrents of Spring? It's parody fiction, but essentially non-fiction because he's writing about (and making fun of) writers he actually knew in person (i.e. Sherwood Anderson).

Of course, it's a relatively simple novella and was really only written so that he could break his publishing contract and switch to another firm, but still.... pretty funny stuff. Though, I do like Sherwood Anderson a lot, so I suppose I should be offended.

Post a new comment

Comments by